Posted by attilachordash on August 22, 2007
Regular (daily, weekly) Journal Clubs are crucially important events in the life of labs. Reviewing other labs’ results is a way to get synchronized with all the data accumulated by a particular subdiscipline. Moreover it is the most obvious everyday form (conferences are not that frequent) of secondary peer review of the given paper, when experts in one lab heavily criticize the story, methods, data and assumptions of experts in the other competitor lab. There is an education component: as the Wikipedia article says Journal Clubs help make the student become more familiar with the advanced literature and help improve the students’ skills of understanding and debating current topics of active interest in their field.
On the philosophical-psychological level a Regular Journal Club continuously confirm the identity and unity of the lab and the functional team behind it.
Now the question is how to move the Journal Club format to the web without losing its merits and retaining its role in a lab’s life?
Short answer: Read the rest of this entry »
Posted in Journal Club, peer-review, presentation, science, technology | 6 Comments »