Pimm – Partial immortalization

A Biotech Geek (micro)Blogger’s adventures through science, technology and the web…

  • email me

    [attilacsordas][at][gmail.com]
  • Attila on Twitter

  • Recent Comments

    First Gadget Reviews on Freeing dark, negative researc…
    Duncan Bayne on How to read PDF files on iPhon…
    Open Source Science … on Google’s Palimpsest proj…
    Reviews New Gadget on Why the Dyna-Vision G1 Android…
    name on How to read PDF files on iPhon…
    Wrinkle Reviews on Terrific Pixar-style Harvard a…
    Bony Yousuf on Systemic regmed
    Face Anti Wrinkle on Rumors on Amatokin: a skin ste…
    Liyal Blog on Rumors on Amatokin: a skin ste…
    Big Tits and Curvy A… on Spit a big in a tube, search w…
  • licence

    Creative Commons License
  • c

  •  

    May 2007
    M T W T F S S
    « Apr   Jun »
     123456
    78910111213
    14151617181920
    21222324252627
    28293031  

Informational emergency in the operating room: does it count as a right?

Posted by attilachordash on May 30, 2007

second opinion coverI found this exciting case in the book (yes, I am still reading those) of Lancet editor-in-chief Richard Horton called: Second Opinion: Doctors, Diseases and Decisions in Modern Medicine

“Surgery is all about action, not reflection. But information is sometimes critical, even in the operating room. In 2002, surgeons in Australia were working frantically to save the life of a critically injured man. One of the surgeons recalled that he had read an article in a medical journal that he was sure would help his team right there and then. The problem was that he could not remember which article. What could he do? A call was put out to the British Library archives. Although it was received at 3 AM British time, library staff were able to track down the 1996 paper in the European Journal of Emergency Medicine within twenty minutes and send it to the desperate Australian surgeons.”

What could be the answer today, in 2007 for that question: What could he do?

PubMed, Google Scholar, Connotea, CiteUlike?

Even if the surgeon found the title or abstract of the paper within seconds with one of these or other apps, would he/she be able to download the whole (copyrighted) content somehow within minutes too without an institutional subscription referring to informational and life emergency?

Could this exceptional information and life emergency be interpreted as a basic right with complementary duties? If yes, as a positive or negative right?What if a perfectly targeted Google app (call it Google Emergency) would be at hand, one that would be able to transiently abandon copyright issues for the sake of human help and solidarity?

2 Responses to “Informational emergency in the operating room: does it count as a right?”

  1. Mission-critical OA!

    While you’re over at Attila’s blog (see the entry below), be sure to read this entry about surgeons in desperate need of information during an operation. Library staff were able to provide the required paper (at 3am!), but the connection with OA is i…

  2. [...] Informational emergency in the operating room — people always roll their eyes when I give them this scenerio… [...]

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>